PA Supreme Court Issues Two Decisions in Favor of Injured Worker Rights

Written by Attorney Michael A. O’Donnell | O’Donnell Law Offices

On November 17, 2026, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court handed down two (2) significant decisions supporting injured workers’ rights. Both decisions stem from George Thomas’ July 1, 2016 work injury with Sysco Foods.

Supreme Court Protects Injured Workers Against Improperly Noticed Independent Medical Examinations

The Supreme Court vacated and reinstated a piece of Mr. Thomas’ benefits that had been terminated. The employer and its insurance company had secured a termination relying upon an Independent Medical Examination arranged by the defense, but which was not disclosed to Mr. Thomas’ attorney. The Supreme Court held that an employer cannot use an Independent Medical Examination to alter the status of an injured worker’s benefits if the employer (or its insurer) directly contacts the injured worker, requests, and conducts an Independent Medical Exam without first notifying the injured worker’s attorney.

In this case, even though the insurance carrier knew that Mr. Thomas was represented by an attorney, the insurer scheduled him for an Independent Medical Examination with one of the insurer’s chosen doctors. Mr. Thomas went to the exam and the doctor wrote a report saying he had fully recovered from a portion of his work-injury-related impairments. The insurance company used that opinion to attack his right to ongoing medical coverage. The trial court and intermediate Courts of Appeals sided with the defense. The Supreme Court reversed finding that the Independent Medical Exam, a litigation driven medical evaluation, was coordinated without the knowledge and input of Mr. Thomas’ attorney. Doing so was prejudicial and should have prevented the insurer from using an improperly noticed Independent Medical Examination to alter the injured worker’s benefits.

Second Supreme Court Decision Addresses Earning Power and Workers’ Compensation Benefits

By separate decision the Supreme Court also reversed a decision from the Intermediate Appellate Court addressing Mr. Thomas’ earning power. There, the employer and its insurer had argued that Mr. Thomas, despite his work-related injuries, possessed the ability to work in a lighter duty capacity. They argued that he was well enough to generate some measure of earnings even though he could not return to his pre-injury work and level of earnings. The employer and insurer sought to modify or reduce what it paid to Mr. Thomas in weekly workers’ compensation disability payments.

How Labor Market Surveys and Earning Capacity Assessments Work

Under Section 306(b)(2) of the Workers’ Compensation Act, Pennsylvania law gives the employer and insurer the option to show an injured worker’s ability to earn a living through something called a Labor Market Survey and Earning Capacity Assessment. Put simply: the employer and insurer will use a jobs expert to identify open job vacancies with other employers and argue that the injured worker has earning power in that he has the physical and intellectual capacity to perform other jobs. If they succeed in persuading a Judge that the work is appropriate then the Court has the authority to reduce the injured worker’s wage loss entitlement based upon the earnings that the outside jobs would provide.

Employers Must Establish That Suitable Work Is Unavailable

But … there is an additional requirement under the law. It must be established that the employer for which the injured person was working at the time of injury does not have suitable work before the Labor Market Survey and Earning Power Assessment can be undertaken. Prior to Thomas, the Commonwealth Court had determined that the injured worker carried the burden to show that their employer had suitable work in order to defeat modification efforts under these circumstances. The practical effect was that employers routinely gave this criteria a passing glance; usually with a supervisor or HR representative issuing a letter saying “we don’t have work within our injured worker’s restrictions.” The burden then shifted to the injured worker to show that work otherwise existed with their employer. This was considerably difficult to establish in most instances because the worker was no longer intimately connected with the employer’s business operations and were left to peruse classified ads and other public postings in an effort to meet their burden.

The Supreme Court interpreted Section 306(b)(2) as requiring the employer to first carry the burden of showing that the they did not have work for the injured worker prior to pursuing Labor Market Survey and Earning Power Assessment challenges. If the employer fails to present competent and persuasive evidence that no such work exists, then the employer cannot meet its burden of proof in order to modify or reduce and injured worker’s wage loss payments based upon other outside work.

What the Thomas Decisions Mean for Injured Workers in Pennsylvania

Independent Medical Examinations are not independent. Labor Market Surveys are not at their core intended to bring an injured worker back to the purposeful and gainful labor market. In reality, both of these tools are used by employers and insurers to limit their exposure and responsibility to pay workers compensation benefits. Both are loaded with landmines, red flags, and other metaphorical traps that could cost workers their benefits and legal rights. The Thomas decisions reinforce the significance of the injured worker’s rights when represented by legal counsel and the appropriate burden allocation when the argument is raised that the worker can or should be back to work while continuing to manage a significant injury.

Concerned About Your Workers’ Compensation Benefits?

If your employer or its insurance company is attempting to reduce, suspend, or terminate your workers’ compensation benefits, understanding your rights is essential.

At O’Donnell Law Offices, our experienced workers’ compensation attorneys represent injured workers throughout Northeastern Pennsylvania. Whether you are facing an Independent Medical Examination, an earning capacity assessment, or a dispute over your benefits, our team is here to help protect your rights.

Consultations are free. Call us, we can help.

Schedule a Free Consultation

Or call 570-821-5717

Comments are closed.